Jim Goodman
And Anthony Pahnke
Chicago Tribune
On Jan. 11, 1944, in his annual State of the Union address, President Franklin Roosevelt noted that while the Constitution guaranteed a set of political rights, they were in some respects inadequate. To ensure equality, Roosevelt proposed an Economic Bill of Rights that would guarantee:
Full employment with an adequate income
Freedom from monopolies and unfair competition
Adequate housing
Adequate health care
Social Security
Fair incomes for farmers
Adequate education
Many items from the Economic Bill of Rights have emerged in the 2020 campaigns, such as the call for affordable housing, antitrust enforcement, Medicare for All and a living wage.
Yet, only Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., have mentioned fair incomes for farmers. Warren, particularly, expressed her support for rural people by endorsing the “Farmers Bill of Rights” — of which fair income is a part — while attending the Family Farm Action rally and The Heartland Forum in Storm Lake, Iowa.
Besides a fair income, just like other workers, the Farmers Bill of Rights seeks to guarantee farmers fair and open markets that are not dominated by a handful of corporations.
It also promotes access to local supply stores, mechanics and processing facilities. And the proposal intends to assure the provision of credit to women, beginning, immigrant and minority farmers, while pushing for reasonable environmental standards for all rural people.
Moreover, the proposition includes the right to transparent and accurate enforcement of production practices, including organic and country of origin labeling, as well as the right to repair our own equipment rather than being forced to pay corporations that feel they still “own” the rights to what we purchase.
Rural people are entitled to the right to live in healthy, vigorous communities that have quality schools, medical care and opportunities for all.
There used to be protections for farmers and consumers. The Packers and Stockyards Act of 1921, which became part of the Grain Inspection, Packers and Stockyards Administration in 1994, was previously known as the Farmers and Ranchers Bill of Rights.
Back in 1921, protection from the predatory practices of the highly consolidated meat packing industry was sorely needed. Yet, in 2017 the Trump administration decided not to finalize the Farmer Fair Practice Rules within GIPSA. The rules clarify what counts as fair trade practices, helping farmers and ranchers understand their rights in the marketplace and to impede corporate overreach. To make matters worse, GIPSA was then absorbed within the Agricultural Marketing Service, whose mission is more oriented to protecting corporate agribusiness’ interests than those of family farmers.
While corporate agribusiness continues to consolidate, with little more than a wink and a nod from regulators, farmers must take the price offered in the marketplace. Now, unlike 1921, the marketplace is a global one that pits farmers against farmers worldwide. Buyers pay as little as possible, driving down prices that farmers receive.
According to the National Farmers Union, farmers earn less than $.15 of every food dollar. As incomes have slumped over the last few years, input costs have increased for feed, seed, fertilizer, fuel and machinery.
Trump’s tariffs on imports from our trading partners and their retaliatory tariffs on our agricultural exports have caused even more pain in rural America. This squeezes farmers and consumers, as even in supermarkets with thousands of brands on the shelf, the reality is, most are owned by a handful of corporations.
So, in addition to Roosevelt’s Economic Bill of Rights that are receiving attention again, those of us in farm country are in desperate need of a Farmers Bill of Rights.
Kudos to Warren for endorsing the Farmers Bill of Rights, and to Sanders for seriously mentioning the farm crisis. As for the other candidates, we wonder when they will get on board and come up with some serious farm policy discussion, some real solutions to the ongoing devastation of rural America.
Jim Goodman is an organic dairy farmer from Wonewoc, Wis., and ANTHONY PAHNKE is the vice president of the Family Farm Defenders and assistant professor of international relations at San Francisco State University.
